April 20, 2026 · 7 min read

GETTING YOUR FIRST TATTOO? 10 THINGS TO KNOW

Your first tattoo is a milestone. It's exciting, maybe a little nerve-wracking, and it's something you'll carry with you for life. Whether you've been planning for years or the idea just clicked yesterday, knowing what to expect will make the experience smoother and the result better.

Here are 10 things every first-timer should know — straight from the artists at Traditional Ink in Middleton, WI.

1. CHOOSE A DESIGN YOU WON'T REGRET

TIP 01

Your first tattoo doesn't need to have deep meaning — but it should be something you genuinely like. Avoid impulse decisions on trendy designs that might feel dated in five years. Classic imagery — roses, daggers, animals, script — has stayed relevant for decades for a reason.

Bring reference images to your consultation. Show your artist what you like in terms of style, placement, and size. They'll work with you to create something custom that fits your body and your vision. Check out our tattoo styles guide to explore different aesthetics.

2. CHOOSE THE RIGHT ARTIST FOR YOUR STYLE

TIP 02

Not every artist does every style equally well. Look at portfolios. At Traditional Ink, our artists each specialize:

• Dan Kurber — American Traditional (bold lines, rich color)
• Damian Acosta — Black & grey realism (photorealistic shading)
• Kenderlyn — Fine line, florals, delicate work

Match your design idea to the artist whose portfolio shows they excel in that style. Don't ask a realism artist to do traditional work, or vice versa.

3. UNDERSTAND THE PAIN — IT'S NOT AS BAD AS YOU THINK

TIP 03

Yes, it hurts. But here's the thing most people don't tell you: your brain releases endorphins during the tattooing process. These natural painkillers kick in within the first few minutes, and many clients find the experience surprisingly manageable — even meditative.

The sensation varies by placement. Outer arms, thighs, and calves tend to be less painful. Ribs, elbows, inner biceps, and feet are more intense. For a first tattoo, choose a meatier spot with more padding between skin and bone.

Most people walk out saying, "That wasn't nearly as bad as I expected."

4. PREPARE YOUR BODY

TIP 04

Set yourself up for success the day of your appointment:

• Eat a solid meal before your session. Low blood sugar makes you lightheaded and increases pain sensitivity.
• Hydrate well the day before and the morning of. Well-hydrated skin takes ink better.
• Get a good night's sleep. Your body handles stress better when rested.
• Wear comfortable, loose clothing that gives easy access to the tattoo area.
• Avoid alcohol for at least 24 hours before. Alcohol thins your blood and increases bleeding, making the artist's job harder and potentially affecting ink retention.
• Skip blood-thinning medications like aspirin or ibuprofen (if medically safe to do so).

5. KNOW WHAT HAPPENS DURING THE SESSION

TIP 05

Here's the typical flow at Traditional Ink:

1. Consultation — You discuss the design, placement, and size with your artist. They may sketch on the spot or schedule the tattoo for a later date if it requires custom drawing time.
2. Stencil placement — A transfer paper stencil is applied to your skin so you can see exactly where and how it will look. You get to approve placement before any needles touch you.
3. Tattooing — The artist works section by section. Outlines first, then shading, then color (if applicable). You can take breaks if needed.
4. Wrap-up — The tattoo is cleaned, photographed, and wrapped. You'll receive aftercare instructions.

Bring headphones, a book, or something to keep you occupied during longer sessions. Feel free to talk to your artist — or zone out. Whatever keeps you comfortable and still.

6. FOLLOW AFTERCARE RELIGIOUSLY

TIP 06

Aftercare is what separates a tattoo that heals perfectly from one that loses color, scars, or gets infected. Your artist will give you specific instructions — follow them exactly. Our full aftercare guide covers everything in detail, but the basics are:

• Wash gently 3-4 times daily with fragrance-free soap
• Apply a thin layer of unscented lotion (Lubriderm or Aveeno)
• Don't pick, scratch, or peel
• Avoid sun, pools, hot tubs, and baths for 2-3 weeks
• Don't re-wrap the tattoo after the initial wrap is removed

Read our article on 5 aftercare mistakes that ruin your ink to learn what NOT to do.

7. UNDERSTAND THE COSTS

TIP 07

At Traditional Ink, our rate is $150 per hour for all artists. A small first tattoo typically takes 1-2 hours. Larger or more complex pieces take longer.

A non-refundable deposit is required to hold a scheduled appointment. The deposit is applied toward your total cost. Walk-ins don't require a deposit — you just pay at the end of the session.

Don't shop based on price alone. A cheap tattoo is expensive in the long run when you end up paying for a cover-up or laser removal. Quality work at a fair hourly rate from a skilled artist is always the better investment.

8. WALK-INS VS. APPOINTMENTS

TIP 08

At Traditional Ink, walk-ins are always welcome during our open hours (Tue-Thu 12-6PM, Fri-Sat 12-8PM). Walk-ins are great for smaller pieces or if you're flexible on artist and timing.

For larger custom pieces, scheduling an appointment ensures your artist has time to draw your design in advance and dedicate a full session to your piece. Book by calling (608) 520-0603 or DMing @traditionaltatz on Instagram.

9. AGE REQUIREMENT: 18+ — NO EXCEPTIONS

TIP 09

In the state of Wisconsin, it is illegal to tattoo anyone under 18 years of age — even with parental consent. This is not a shop policy; it's state law. No reputable shop will bend this rule.

Bring a valid photo ID (driver's license, state ID, or passport). If you can't prove you're 18, you won't be tattooed. Period.

10. TIPPING YOUR ARTIST

TIP 10

Tipping is not required but is customary and appreciated. The standard range is 15-25% of the total cost. If your artist spent extra time on a custom design, went above and beyond on detail, or you're especially happy with the result, tipping on the higher end is a great way to show appreciation.

Cash tips are preferred but not required. You can also add a tip to a card payment.

BONUS: HOW TO FIND THE RIGHT SHOP

Not all tattoo shops are created equal. Here's what to look for:

• Cleanliness — The shop should be spotless. Single-use needles, sterilized equipment, gloves worn at all times.
• Portfolio quality — Look at healed photos, not just fresh work. Healed tattoos tell the real story.
• Reviews — Check Google reviews. Traditional Ink has 111 five-star reviews for a reason.
• Vibe — You should feel comfortable and welcome, not rushed or pressured.
• Specialization — A shop with artists who specialize in different styles means you'll get matched with the right person for your piece.

At Traditional Ink, we check every box. Come see for yourself — 2229 Parmenter St, Middleton, WI. Walk-ins welcome.